Tuesday, September 12, 2006

Terrorism versus Islam

I have not done anything significant this past week, except may be go up the Eiffel Tower and enjoy a stunning view of Paris..so I shall use this week's post to speak about something else...the villification of Muslims across the world

Yes, I, a Hindu..a Brahmin..am going to dedicate a post extending my sympathy to the Muslim community...and No, I have not taken leave of my senses..

As the world celebrates the 5th Anniversary of the 9/11 attack on the WTC, various news channels have also covered the change in the way the world now perceives Muslims. They are all looked upon in askance..as if being a Muslim is a sure fire way of identifying a potential terrorist. All Muslims are not terrorists just like all Germans are not Hitler's...all Marathis are not Nathuram Godse's and all Lankans are not Ravanas...

So, everytime we have a terrorist attack, a new wave of scathing comments are thrown at Muslims across the world. No, I most certainly don't condone these acts of terrorism..but I don't think these attacks are a license to attack Muslims..

Terrorism has no religion...no God-fearing person can execute thousands of innocents for no fault of their own. Yes, the terrorists use their religion as their potent weapon…they use the name of God to claim innocent lives…their War on Jihad is part of their plan to destroy all non believers’ of Islam..

Jihad is an Islamic term, which connotes a wide range of meanings: anything from an inward spiritual struggle to attain perfect faith to a political or military struggle to further the Islamic cause. Muslim scholars explained there are five kinds of jihad fi sabilillah (struggle in the cause of God).

1. Jihad of the heart/soul (jihad bin nafs/qalb) is an inner struggle of good against evil in the mind.
2. Jihad by the tongue (jihad bil lisan) is a struggle of good against evil waged by writing and speech, such as in the form of dawah (proselytizing), Khutbas (sermons), and political or military propaganda.
3. Jihad by the pen and knowledge (jihad bil qalam/ilm) is a struggle for good against evil through scholarly study of Islam, ijtihad (legal reasoning), and through sciences (such as military and medical sciences).
4. Jihad by the hand (jihad bil yad) refers to a struggle of good against evil waged by actions or with one's wealth, such as going on the Hajj pilgrimage (seen as the best jihad for women), taking care of elderly parents, providing funding for jihad, political activity for furthering the cause of Islam, stopping evil by force, or espionage.
5. Jihad by the sword (jihad bis saif) refers to qital fi sabilillah (armed fighting in the way of God, or holy war).

It is the last interpretation of Jihad that is the reason behind this holy war. But, even Islam or the Quran does not allow the murder of innocents in Jihad. Physical Jihad relates to the use of physical force in defence of Muslims against oppression and transgression by the enemies of Allah, Islam and Muslims. Allah commands that Muslims lead peaceful lives and not transgress against anyone. If they are persecuted and oppressed, the Qur'an recommends that they migrate to a more peaceful and tolerant land: "Lo! Those who believe, and those who emigrate (to escape persecution) and strive (Jahadu) in the way of Allah, these have hope of Allah's mercy..." (2:218). If relocation is not possible, then Allah also requires Muslims to defend themselves against oppression by "fighting against those who fight against us." 2 The Qur'an states: "To those against whom war is made, permission is given [to defend themselves], because they are wronged - and verily, Allah is Most Powerful to give them victory." (22:39) [4]

Jihad is a supposed to be a fight against those who wrong Muslims or Islam. Being a Christian or a Hindu or a Jew is not a crime against Muslims or Islam. The very base behind this War of Jihad is wrong. The Muslim Jihad has been the compared to the Christian crusade centuries ago, where people were made to convert to Christianity. A person should be allowed to choose his/her own faith. Holding someone at gunpoint and asking him to worship Allah is not a means of converting faith. This War on Jihad is not based on Islam or people who have wronged it. Terrorism and murder as opposed to religion or God are the rules that govern it.

So, basically, I am trying to make a point here, that acts of terrorism, for the most part have no bearing on god-fearing Muslims across the world who have also lost their kith and kin in these attacks. We should not use these attacks to victimize Muslims and possibly alienate them further.

If there are any Muslims reading this blog, then I urge you to ask your community to be more vocal and active in the War against terrorism. The Muslim community should condemn these acts with no if's and buts’. They should not use these acts of Terrorism as a means to ask for upliftment from poverty or better rights to education as is the case in Britain. Poverty and illiteracy are independent of a person's religious background and are not reasons for the Muslims to condone terrorism.

Countries like Lebanon are democracies. The people of these countries can go a long way in fighting the war against terrorism if they elect leaders who will show the world that they are also opposed to Terrorism as opposed to electing to power Terrorist outfits like the Hezbollah. The Muslim community could also go a long way in preaching religious tolerance. Not being Muslim does not make us any less human. This would be the right time to put in Shylock the Jew’s dialogue in Merchant of Venice..

"Hath not a Jew eyes? Hath not a Jew hands, organs, dimensions, senses, affections, passions; fed with the same food, hurt with the same weapons, subject to the same diseases, healed by the same means, warmed and cooled by the same winter and summer as a Christian is? If you prick us do we not bleed? If you tickle us do we not laugh? If you poison us do we not die? And if you wrong us shall we not revenge? If we are like you in the rest, we will resemble you in that."

There it was said from a Jew to a Christian..here it is being said from a Hindu to a Muslim. The point remains the same. We are as human as you are. So help us put an end to this madness. Let the world finally become a safe place to live in.

Warning...I know this post will evoke some very strong feelings among my readers...but please remember...this post is only about Islam vis-a-vis terrorism..please dont expand this to other facets of Islam notably their treatment of women etc...

8 comments:

JayaPrakash S said...

whoever said Islam rhymes with terrorism has to read this.. pretty good post... I have to say well knit...

However the downside if this post is that it does not seem to cover about the fact that majority of the terrorist activities that take place accross the globe are orchestrated by Muslims. let it be 9/11 or 7/11.... and the percentage of muslims who are terrorists are defenetely more that the percentage in Hindu/Sikhs/Christianity... that automatically leads us to the conclusion that a good number of terrorists are muslims...

also the mentality of these people are so weak that they can be easily lured into terrorism using poverty and cause of god(allah) as weapons.. no wonder the words rhyme....

ganesh said...

Excellent post… well written. Enjoyed reading it. Inclusion of the Judaism-Christianity strengthened the matter. The post opened up my eyes about Jihad… I had a complete different meaning in mind…looking at what’s happening around its not at all my fault!

Would like to clarify few things before I comment:
1. You are not saying Islam is superior to any other religion.
2. You are talking about how Islam in general is blamed for all the terrorism.
3. You are also not saying that all Muslims are innocent.

If all the aforesaid are true then I completely agree to whatever you mentioned. You can stop reading this right now! And I am sure after reading your post Prophet Mohammed will say: “Bless you child, you will have 17 kids.

[Stop if you agree: don’t continue. You should not be reading this. ]

On the contrary, would like to talk about religion, terrorism, and people in accordance with Islam:

Religion: I don’t have any aversion towards Islam. I respect it as a religion. I think all religions preach the same, just in their own way. But times are changing and so are the religions. Islam is no exception. They can’t be in the same shell forever. Its how they cope up with this change that matters.

[If you are still reading it …shame on u :-p ]

Terrorism: As you have mentioned, you can’t deny the fact that terrorism is related to Islam. All Muslims are not terrorists, but all terrorists are Muslims – Courtesy The Week – don’t remember the author. Now why is this??? There are terrorists/militants from all religion, then why the special place for Islam terrorists. Is it because unlike other religion terrorist group they cause more carnage, are more effective, and are feared the most worldwide? Yes, and is Islam is to be blamed for it? Again, Yes. Let me be clear, Islam as a religion is not to be blamed but the way it is imparted to such youths definitely is to be condemned. So finally it’s Islam that’s driving them.

People: So why is that the Muslim youths are drawn towards terrorism? Its mainly because they are brain-washed (religiously) about what is (a)moral. Education would have definitely helped. But then how can they get enough of it when they have a battalion for a family? In the abject state that they live, terrorism is the easy, lucrative way out. There’s nothing wrong in having a BIG family, if it can be well supported. Look at our Dear Laloo Prasad Yadav, double digits and still going strong. He even got his eldest daughter Misa first rank in Med school! Coming back to BIG families, who is to blame for this? Islam(choose not to explain) or People(who follow Islam)???. I don’t think the people are to be blamed, they are just following their religion. Changes to such customs are dire. Don’t get me wrong; this is just a part of the community and this exists in other religions as well. There are many honorable Muslim dignitaries and the other part of the community because which Islam is not completely shunned (the reason for this blog). One such individual is our Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam. In the entire India constituency he undoubtedly holds the highest regards. My solemn gratitude to this part.

[Guess u have read everything … just like to say these are just my views. I have no irreverence towards Islam.]

One cannot just turn a blind eye to this Islam + terrorism issue which is becoming prominent day by day. Lets just hope it does not end grimly.

JayaPrakash S said...

Probably you could move this post under different blog and keep this purely for paris vist...

well said ganesh...

I agree to the fact that " All Muslims are not terrorist, But All(huge Majority) of terrorists are muslims"

JayaPrakash S said...

anu... you are taking the side of your (G)Friend.. Why didn't I expect it....

Islam preaches conversion by force... and what about all the attrocities created due to this a century back. Even today that fuels a lot of act leading to terrorism

Their hatred against US is well understood but is this(terrorism) way to try and control them.

I am not taking the side of US who believe that "for peace we need to rage war"... thats a tragedy in itself..

I would say... it is not 'Terrorism versus Islam'.... rather 'Terrorism is Islam' and I reiterate it is not Islam is terrorism.

Amu said...

This post is not about taking sides..it is not preaching about right or wrong..not is it advocating love for Islam...

Yes Ganesh..ur right..all terrorists these days are Muslims..but as I said in this post..terrorism has no religion..

But yes, the way Islam is being preached is wrong and is conducive to creating terrorists out of innocents..The Muslim community at large..and these are the Muslims I am addressing in my post should do something about this..

The Bible also advocates "An eye for an eye..a tooth for a tooth"..yet we dont see Christian suicide bombers blowing themselves up in Arab countries..My point is..Islam is more than about Jihad..let Muslims focus on that and stop making Jihad the focus of their religion..

ganesh said...

@amu: I AGREE TO EVERYTHING U SAY.
But this discussion is incompletely (not even close) without taking sides.

Who will teach the Muslims proper Islam??...can’t be us. Don’t you think they should be smart enough to differentiate between religion and terrorism? All we can do is critique and argue. Or in other word take sides. And I am not on Islam’s side.

JayaPrakash S said...

Not taking sides ?!?!?

it is taking the side of Muslims... largest religion in the world ( why not with the 17+ children ). you do have the larger supporting group. But not for the right cause though.

Terrorism is not a religion, But Islam is.... and damn a good one producing a lot of terrorists...

It is easy to say and agree with you about Islam and terrorism when it comes to 9/11 only. but what about Afghanistan supporting you know who. and pakistan training people in the name of same religion against india, and Iraq/Iran I do not have to comment...

Hell will break loose if I go on.. and I will not online...

If i were a security personal in an airport I will look at every muslim with suspision and I have every reason to be. I am sure you will bo too and so witll sheil abdul khan do.. If he is a sincere security.

that is only because of the numbers. they speakto themselves.

Kishan said...

@Amu,
Kudos for all the great information about Jihad. i didnt really know so much about Jihad. a great post, and an interesting discussion...

I would say it is unfair to blame a religion, just because we haven't (still) heard of non-Islamic terrorism.

I still wish the world was a much simpler, peaceful place to live in...yeah! I know I am dreaming and probably expecting too much!

Anyways, Few months back, disturbed by all these, had posted this one.. , just wondering why all these hatred, violence first started in the first place.... one thing that came into mind was "Did civilization make our lives more and more complex?". take a look at it...